Sociology teaches that although social forces are not always visible, they are constantly at work, shaping relationships, systems, and experience. In a recent chapter titled “A Critical Manifesto for the Sociology of Mental Health”, sociologist Bruce Cohen, writing from New Zealand, urges the field of psychiatry to grapple with this reality.
Writing from New Zealand, Cohen makes a forceful case for the inclusion of sociological frameworks in mental health research and practice, arguing that psychiatry cannot be understood, or transformed, without first recognizing its role in reproducing social hierarchies.
“Whether you are based in neuroscience, psychology, chemistry, or the humanities,” Cohen writes, “sociological insight and explorations of mental health and illness are of profound significance to modern research endeavours as they provide understandings, interpretations, and theories which can go beyond pathology, disease labels, and the current hegemony of the biomedical model.”
The chapter appears in the edited volume Zur Gesellschaft der verletzten Seelen: Neue soziologische Perspektiven auf Psychiatrie, Gesellschaft und Subjekt (Volume title in original German—translated as On the Society of Wounded Souls: New Sociological Perspectives on Psychiatry, Society, and the Subject).
Cohen’s “critical manifesto” traces how mental distress is often socially produced and politically managed, and why any effort to rethink mental health must also interrogate the institutions and ideologies that shape what counts as illness and who gets to decide.
You've landed on a MIA journalism article that is funded by MIA supporters. To read the full article, sign up as a MIA Supporter. All active donors get full access to all MIA content, and free passes to all Mad in America events.
Current MIA supporters can log in below.(If you can't afford to support MIA in this way, email us at [email protected] and we will provide you with access to all donor-supported content.)
As a Sociology graduate and psychiatry survivor I pretty much agree with the entire sentiment.
Mental Health is a Social Science, not a Medical Discipline.
End of!
Report comment
Please no- no more discourse. Too many years blathering; too many lives destroyed and lost. Where has the discourse gotten us?
Report comment
I couldn’t agree more, AnnieOakley.
Report comment
Certainly sociologists should study this field. But they rely to some extent on the model of human existence provided to them by Psychology, and that model is deeply flawed.
It is Psychology that needs to be solved. A proper solution would benefit not only the field of “mental health,” but would probably destroy Psychiatry’s control of the subject, would greatly reduce the use of meds, and would also revolutionize all the social sciences, as well as the physical sciences.
What people need most is a proper, workable understanding of themselves. Too bad sociology has not provided us with that.
Report comment