New Book by Courageous Psychiatrist about Her Profession’s Most Damaging Falsehood

5
1253

Writing in CounterPunch, Bruce Levine reviews Joanna Moncrieff’s new book Chemically Imbalanced.

“To be clear, Moncrieff is not anti-drug, but rather anti-bullshitting patients about psychiatric drugs. While antidepressants don’t work by correcting any mythical chemical imbalance, it is true that studies show that from 25 to 35 percent of depressed patients report short-term benefits; however, those receiving a placebo do just as well. And in the long term, more depressed people remit from depression without antidepressants than by using them.

When taking antidepressants, as is the case with any psychotropic drug, there is going to be a placebo effect, and because of the noticeable side effects of antidepressants, this placebo effect is what scientists call an “amplified” one. Moncrieff notes, “Alongside placebo and amplified placebo effects, there is the possibility that antidepressants improve people’s depression scores by numbing their emotions . . . . People frequently described a numbing or blunting of emotions . . . . They reported being less in touch with their feelings, being unable to cry, feeling uncaring or unmotivated, and some felt they were no longer themselves.”

Some people, at least for a time, might prefer this emotional blunting, but this is not curing depression. Moreover, antidepressants create all types of adverse effects, including sexual dysfunction and severe withdrawal problems, especially with long-term use.”

Article →

Photo by Damir Samatkulov

5 COMMENTS

  1. Yes, these.drugs (not to mention antipsychotics) cause SE’s and other medical problems yet to be recognized. I’ve taken them for over 50 yrs, with many.physical conditions, some of which are potentially fatal.@ any time. Also, the older I get the doses of my youth have had to be reduced to minidoses. For many years I lost my creative abilities (try to explain that to a psychiatrist) because I was taking too large amounts. Doctors have blatantly thought I was delusional about my creative accomplishments-including my religious vows. When I finally showed the proof of these there were.some very red faces. God’s.gifts to me include helping to make the world a better place for the mentally ill (plus, I’m a well-educated ret. Psych RN.) We are all God’s children-unique and.precious.
    Lovingly yours…

    Report comment

  2. I want to add an addendum to above note… I have tried to live a hidden life for many years… but now it is time for those whom I serve… know my true identity as a “religiious in the world.” This is not grandiose of me but I am a servant of God and holy Mother Church. I particularly am missioned to help heal the wounded-particularly those traumatized by current psychiatric care. It happened to me. I hope this helps the confusion which could accompany my replies. Sr. Mary Marcelyn Madden. Many thanks!

    Report comment

LEAVE A REPLY